Which Mercedes CLS is the best?

The Mercedes-Benz CLS-Class is a luxury four-door coupe that has consistently captivated car enthusiasts with its sleek design, powerful engines, and opulent interiors. Spanning three generations, the CLS has offered a range of models, each with its own unique blend of performance, technology, and style. Choosing the "best" CLS ultimately depends on individual priorities and preferences, but a comprehensive comparison can help potential buyers make an informed decision.

This article will delve into the specifics of each generation, highlighting their strengths and weaknesses to determine which CLS model stands out as the most desirable.

Mercedes-Benz CLS Generations: A Quick Overview

Detailed Explanations

First Generation (C219): 2004-2010

The original CLS, the C219, revolutionized the automotive landscape with its groundbreaking four-door coupe design. It combined the elegance of a coupe with the practicality of a sedan, setting a new trend in the luxury car market. The C219 offered a range of powerful engines, including various V6 and V8 options, culminating in the ferocious CLS 63 AMG, boasting a naturally aspirated 6.2-liter V8. The interior was lavishly appointed with premium materials, offering a comfortable and luxurious driving experience. However, early models could suffer from electronic gremlins, and the rear headroom was somewhat limited due to the sloping roofline.

Second Generation (C218): 2011-2018

The second-generation CLS, the C218, built upon the success of its predecessor with a more aggressive and sculpted design. It retained the iconic coupe-like silhouette but incorporated sharper lines and a more pronounced front grille. The C218 introduced more fuel-efficient engine options, including turbocharged four-cylinder and V6 units, alongside the powerful V8s. Technological advancements included improved driver-assistance systems such as lane keeping assist and blind-spot monitoring. While the C218 offered a more modern driving experience, some critics found the styling less elegant than the original, and the ride quality could be firm, especially on models with larger wheels.

Third Generation (C257): 2018-2024

The third-generation CLS, the C257, represents a further evolution of the design language, with a focus on refinement and technology. It features a sleek and sophisticated exterior design, with a more streamlined profile and distinctive LED lighting. The C257 introduced mild-hybrid powertrains, combining a turbocharged engine with an electric motor for improved fuel efficiency and performance. The interior is a showcase of modern luxury, with dual 12.3-inch displays and advanced infotainment features. The C257 prioritizes comfort and refinement, offering a smooth and quiet ride. However, the more aggressive styling of the previous generation was toned down, and some found the design less distinctive. The CLS 53 AMG is a standout, offering a potent combination of performance and luxury.

Detailed Comparison

To help you decide which CLS is the best for you, let's delve into specific aspects of each generation:

Design and Styling

• C219 (2004-2010): Pioneering design, elegant and flowing lines, a timeless classic. The original CLS is often praised for its purity of design and its ability to turn heads. The long hood, sloping roofline, and frameless doors created a striking silhouette that revolutionized the sedan market.
• C218 (2011-2018): More aggressive and sculpted, sharper lines, distinctive front grille. The C218 represents a bolder interpretation of the CLS design, with more pronounced creases and a more imposing presence. While some appreciate the more modern aesthetic, others find it less elegant than the original.
• C257 (2018-2024): Refined and sophisticated, streamlined profile, distinctive LED lighting. The C257 offers a more understated and contemporary design, with a focus on aerodynamic efficiency and visual harmony. The sleek lines and advanced lighting technology create a sophisticated and modern look.

Performance and Engines

• C219 (2004-2010): Range of V6 and V8 engines, powerful CLS 63 AMG with a naturally aspirated 6.2-liter V8. The C219 offered a variety of engine options to suit different driving styles, from the smooth and refined V6s to the exhilarating V8s. The CLS 63 AMG was a true performance icon, delivering blistering acceleration and a thrilling exhaust note.
• C218 (2011-2018): More fuel-efficient engine options, including turbocharged four-cylinder and V6 units, along with powerful V8s. The C218 introduced more fuel-efficient engine options, making it a more practical choice for daily driving. However, the V8 models still offered impressive performance, with the CLS 63 AMG continuing to be a formidable competitor.
• C257 (2018-2024): Mild-hybrid powertrains, combining a turbocharged engine with an electric motor for improved fuel efficiency and performance. The C257 utilizes mild-hybrid technology to enhance both fuel efficiency and performance. The electric motor provides a boost of power during acceleration, resulting in a smoother and more responsive driving experience. The CLS 53 AMG offers a potent combination of performance and efficiency.

Technology and Features

• C219 (2004-2010): Luxurious interior, but older technology. The C219 offered a luxurious interior with premium materials and comfortable seating. However, the technology was relatively dated compared to more modern vehicles.
• C218 (2011-2018): Improved driver-assistance systems, more advanced infotainment. The C218 featured improved driver-assistance systems such as lane keeping assist and blind-spot monitoring, enhancing safety and convenience. The infotainment system was also more advanced than the C219, offering features such as navigation and smartphone integration.
• C257 (2018-2024): Cutting-edge technology, dual 12.3-inch displays, advanced infotainment features. The C257 boasts a state-of-the-art technology suite, with dual 12.3-inch displays that provide a wealth of information and entertainment. The advanced infotainment system offers features such as voice control, augmented reality navigation, and over-the-air updates.

Reliability and Maintenance

• C219 (2004-2010): Early models can suffer from electronic gremlins, potential for higher maintenance costs due to age. The C219 is known for potential electronic issues, particularly in early models. Due to its age, maintenance costs can also be higher compared to newer models.
• C218 (2011-2018): Generally more reliable than the C219, but potential for issues with complex systems. The C218 is generally considered to be more reliable than the C219, but it is still important to be aware of potential issues with its complex systems.
• C257 (2018-2024): Newer model, potentially more reliable, but complex technology can be costly to repair. The C257 is the newest model, so it is likely to be more reliable than the older generations. However, its complex technology can be costly to repair if issues arise.

Practicality

• C219 (2004-2010): Limited rear headroom due to sloping roofline. The sloping roofline of the C219 compromises rear headroom, making it less suitable for taller passengers.
• C218 (2011-2018): Improved rear headroom compared to the C219. The C218 offers slightly improved rear headroom compared to the C219, but it is still not as spacious as a traditional sedan.
• C257 (2018-2024): Similar rear headroom to the C218. The C257 offers similar rear headroom to the C218, making it a comfortable choice for most passengers.

Which CLS is Right for You?

The "best" Mercedes-Benz CLS depends entirely on your individual needs and preferences:

• For the design purist: The C219 (2004-2010) remains a timeless classic, offering a unique and elegant design that still turns heads today.

• For the performance enthusiast: The CLS 63 AMG models from any generation deliver exhilarating performance, with the C219 and C218 offering the raw power of naturally aspirated V8 engines.

• For the technology aficionado: The C257 (2018-2024) is the clear winner, boasting cutting-edge technology, advanced driver-assistance systems, and a luxurious interior.

• For the budget-conscious buyer: The C218 (2011-2018) offers a good balance of style, performance, and technology at a more accessible price point.

Before making a decision, thoroughly research the specific model you're interested in, paying attention to its maintenance history and potential issues. Consider test driving different generations to experience their unique characteristics firsthand.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which CLS generation is the most reliable?

The C218 (2011-2018) and C257 (2018-2024) are generally considered more reliable than the C219 (2004-2010), but all models can have potential issues. Regular maintenance and a thorough pre-purchase inspection are crucial.

What are the common problems with the C219 CLS?

Common issues include electronic glitches, air suspension problems, and rust. A thorough inspection is recommended before purchasing.

Is the CLS a good car for long trips?

Yes, all CLS generations are comfortable and well-suited for long trips, offering a smooth ride and ample space for passengers and luggage.

How does the CLS compare to the Mercedes-Benz E-Class?

The CLS is a more stylish and coupe-like alternative to the E-Class, offering a similar level of luxury and performance but with a more distinctive design. The E-Class typically offers more rear headroom.

What is the fuel economy like on a CLS?

Fuel economy varies depending on the engine and driving style. The newer generations with turbocharged engines and mild-hybrid technology generally offer better fuel economy.

Conclusion

Choosing the "best" Mercedes-Benz CLS is a matter of personal preference. The original C219 is a design icon, while the later generations offer improved technology and efficiency. Carefully consider your priorities and budget to find the CLS that perfectly suits your needs.