Which Ford Focus Is The Best?

The Ford Focus, a compact car produced from 1998 to 2018 (and still in production in some markets), offered a compelling blend of practicality, performance, and affordability. With multiple generations, body styles, and trim levels, choosing the "best" Focus can be a challenge. This article aims to provide a comprehensive guide to help you determine which Ford Focus best suits your needs, considering factors like reliability, fuel economy, performance, and features.

Selecting the best Ford Focus depends entirely on individual priorities. Whether you're seeking a fuel-efficient commuter, a sporty hatchback, or a reliable family car, understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each generation and trim is crucial.

Ford Focus Generations Overview

Detailed Explanations

First Generation (Mk1) - 1998-2007

The Mk1 Focus was a game-changer in the compact car market, known for its sharp handling and distinctive styling. It was available in various body styles, including hatchback, sedan, and wagon. While affordable and fun to drive, the Mk1 can suffer from age-related issues and some reliability concerns, particularly with earlier models. Common problems include issues with the cooling system and electrical components.

Second Generation (Mk2 & Mk2.5) - 2004-2011

The Mk2 Focus brought improvements in refinement and safety compared to its predecessor. The Mk2.5 facelift in 2008 introduced updated styling and improved interior materials. This generation offers a good balance of affordability and features, but it's crucial to inspect the vehicle thoroughly for potential issues, especially with automatic transmissions, which can be prone to problems. Engine options were varied, offering a range of fuel efficiency and performance.

Third Generation (Mk3) - 2011-2018

The Mk3 Focus featured a more modern design and introduced advanced technology, including the MyFord Touch infotainment system. However, the Powershift automatic transmission, particularly in models produced between 2012 and 2016, became notorious for its jerky shifting and potential for failure. This generation also saw the introduction of the high-performance ST and RS models, which offered significantly improved handling and power. If considering a Mk3 with an automatic transmission, research the specific model year and transmission type carefully.

Fourth Generation (Mk4) - 2018-Present (Not available in North America)

The Mk4 Focus is a highly refined and technologically advanced compact car. Unfortunately, it is not available in the US and Canadian markets. It boasts excellent handling, a comfortable ride, and a range of advanced driver-assistance systems.

Choosing the Right Ford Focus: Key Considerations

To determine the "best" Ford Focus for your needs, consider the following factors:

• Budget: How much are you willing to spend? Older models will be more affordable but may require more maintenance.
• Reliability: Are you looking for a car with a proven track record for reliability? Research common issues for each generation and model year.
• Fuel Economy: How important is fuel efficiency to you? Different engine options offer varying levels of fuel economy.
• Performance: Do you prioritize sporty handling and acceleration? Consider the ST or RS models for enhanced performance.
• Features: What features are essential to you, such as advanced safety technology, infotainment systems, or specific body styles?
• Transmission: Manual or Automatic? Be particularly cautious with the Powershift automatic transmission in the Mk3 generation.
• Maintenance: Can you handle basic maintenance, or will you need to rely on a mechanic? Older models may require more frequent maintenance.

Specific Model Recommendations

Based on different needs, here are some specific Ford Focus recommendations:

• Best Budget Option: A well-maintained Mk1 or Mk2 Focus with a manual transmission. Look for a model with a solid service history and no major mechanical issues.
• Best Fuel Economy: The Mk3 Focus with the 1.0-liter EcoBoost engine (if available) or a diesel engine (in markets where offered).
• Best Performance (Affordable): The Mk2 Focus ST offers a good balance of performance and affordability.
• Best Performance (High-End): The Mk3 Focus RS is a performance powerhouse, but be prepared for higher running costs.
• Best Daily Driver (Reliability Focused): The Mk2.5 Focus with a manual transmission and a naturally aspirated engine.
• Best Technology (US Market): The late-model Mk3 Focus with the updated infotainment system (avoiding the problematic Powershift transmission).

Detailed Look at Specific Models

Ford Focus ST (Mk2 & Mk3)

The ST models represent a significant step up in performance. The Mk2 ST features a 2.5-liter turbocharged five-cylinder engine, while the Mk3 ST uses a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder. Both offer improved handling, sportier styling, and a more engaging driving experience. However, be aware that these models may have been driven hard, so a thorough inspection is crucial.

Ford Focus RS (Mk3)

The Mk3 Focus RS is a true performance icon, boasting a 2.3-liter turbocharged engine, all-wheel drive, and a host of performance-enhancing features. It delivers exceptional handling and acceleration, making it a thrilling car to drive. However, the RS commands a premium price and may not be the most practical choice for everyday use. It's also important to note that the RS requires premium fuel and may have higher maintenance costs.

Ford Focus Electric (Mk3)

The Ford Focus Electric was an all-electric version of the Mk3 Focus. While it offered zero-emission driving, its range was limited compared to newer electric vehicles. It's a good option for short commutes and city driving, but it may not be suitable for long trips. Battery degradation can also be a concern with older electric vehicles, so a battery health check is recommended.

Powershift Transmission Issues (Mk3)

The Powershift automatic transmission in the Mk3 Focus (primarily models from 2012-2016) has been widely criticized for its jerky shifting, hesitation, and potential for failure. This transmission uses a dual-clutch design, but it was prone to overheating and premature wear. If you are considering a Mk3 Focus with an automatic transmission, it is essential to research the specific model year and transmission type. Look for evidence of transmission repairs or replacements in the vehicle's service history. A manual transmission is generally a safer bet for reliability.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Which Ford Focus is the most reliable? The Mk2.5 Focus with a manual transmission and a naturally aspirated engine is generally considered to be the most reliable.

• Is the Ford Focus Powershift transmission problematic? Yes, the Powershift automatic transmission in the Mk3 Focus (2012-2016) is known for its issues.

• Are Ford Focus ST models expensive to maintain? ST models generally have higher maintenance costs due to their performance-oriented components.

• Is the Ford Focus a good first car? Yes, the Ford Focus can be a good first car, especially older models, due to their affordability and ease of driving.

• What is the fuel economy like on a Ford Focus? Fuel economy varies depending on the engine and model year. The 1.0-liter EcoBoost engine offers excellent fuel economy.

Conclusion

Choosing the "best" Ford Focus depends on your individual needs and priorities. The Mk1 and Mk2 offer affordability, while the Mk3 boasts modern styling and technology (with caution regarding the Powershift transmission). The ST and RS models provide enhanced performance, but at a higher cost. Careful research, thorough inspection, and consideration of potential issues are crucial when selecting a used Ford Focus. Ultimately, the best Focus is the one that meets your needs, fits your budget, and provides reliable transportation.